posted on 2025-05-09, 19:35authored byNick Mansfield
We live in an era of the deconstruction of borders. Deconstruction does not abolish or erase principles or identities. It shows up their contingency, even as they continue to operate, sometimes more ruthlessly than ever. Deconstruction has a logic of “both/and”: things are both fixed and unstable, both true and meaningless, both self-identical and in an irreducible relationship with the other. Indeed, in deconstruction, self-identity arises only in relation to what is different, what is distinct from you and in distinguishing you, becomes a necessary part of what you are. We live in an era of the deconstruction of borders because we know that borders are constructions, the consequence of historical decisions by colonial administrators as they abandoned ex-colonies to their fate, or the outcome of wars fought to a standstill here at this particular point rather than somewhere else, or the result of the more or less accidentalchoice of one geographical feature—a mountain range or river—as a natural boundary between ethnic groups, themselves constructions of a similar kind of historical contingency. Yet, borders are both constructions and fixtures, both contingent and eternal. It's easy to draw attention to their contingency, yet they still hurt, and the current suffering of refugees is the most pressing present example of their cruelty. Borders are both accidental and fixed, both arbitrary and rigid, both inviting and excluding. Nothing is more typical of their present deconstructed state than the contradiction in their nature in the contemporary world.
History
Journal title
Humanity
Volume
7
Publisher
University of Newcastle/Macquarie University
Language
en, English
College/Research Centre
Faculty of Education and Arts
School
School of Humanities and Social Science
Rights statement
NewMac Humanity Journal applies the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unreported Licence to all articles, with the principle that there should be no financial barriers to access to information. The Attribution-Noncommercial Licence https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/legalcode) allows people freely copy, distribute, remix, and build upon contributors’ work, provided it is not used to make a profit and the original authors and NewMac Humanity Journal are appropriately acknowledged. These conditions can be waived if author, as copyright holder, grants potential users explicit permission. Copyrighted material may be included in articles provided authors duly acknowledge source or provide proof of written permission for such use from the copyright holder.