A critical analysis of turbulence modulation in particulate flow systems: A review of the experimental studies

In multiphase particulate systems, the turbulence of the continuous phase (gas or liquid) is modulated due to interactions between the continuous phase and the suspended particles. Such phenomena are non-trivial in the essence that addition of a dispersed phase to a turbulent flow complicates the existing flow patterns depending on the physical properties of the particles leading to either augmentation or attenuation of continuous phase turbulence. In the present study, this aspect has been comprehensively analysed based on the available experimental data obtained from the well-studied turbulent flow systems such as channel and pipes, free jets and grids. Relevant non-dimensional parameters such as particle diameter to integral length scale ratio, Stokes number, particle volume fraction, particle momentum number, and particle Reynolds number have been utilised to characterise the reported turbulence modulation behavior. Some limitations of these commonly used dimensionless parameters to characterise turbulence modulation are discussed, and possible improvements are suggested.